Public Policy and the Lottery

The drawing of lots to determine property rights and other matters has a long history, going back at least to the Bible, and it became common in Europe in the fifteenth century. The first recorded public lotteries to sell tickets with prize money for winning numbers appeared in the towns of Ghent, Utrecht, and Bruges in the 15th century, raising funds for town fortifications, aiding the poor, or other purposes. After that, many more public lotteries were established. Lotteries are now operated by almost all states in the United States and many in other countries.

The lottery is an extremely complex form of gambling that is not well understood by the general public or even by many state officials who oversee it. This lack of understanding reflects the nature of lotteries as state enterprises that, like other private businesses, have broad public support but must compete with each other to maximize revenue and attract customers. As a result, state policy in this area is often made piecemeal and incrementally by various agencies without the benefit of an overall overview of the industry. This is a classic case of public policy being at cross-purposes with the continued evolution of a business, and this is one reason why lottery critics frequently accuse the industry of engaging in deceptive marketing practices.

A primary challenge for lottery operators is deciding how much of a budget to allocate to advertising. This is a complex tradeoff because too little money spent on promotion might undermine the public’s willingness to support the operation, or it might reduce the amount of prize money available for winners. On the other hand, too much money spent on promotion might not produce the desired results.

Moreover, the promotional messages that are most effective for increasing sales may be unpopular with some groups. Lottery ads are criticized for exaggerating the odds of winning, portraying lottery players as compulsive gamblers, and inflating the value of prize money (the amount won in a typical jackpot is paid in annual installments over 20 years, with inflation and taxes dramatically eroding its current value). Some critics charge that the marketing messages are intentionally deceptive to encourage more playing by people who do not have the financial resources to do so otherwise.

Whether or not such criticism is valid, there is no doubt that lotteries are highly profitable for state governments. The success of state lotteries has encouraged other private enterprises to launch lotteries, as well as companies to provide services to the industry, such as ticket printing and distribution. Lottery revenue is now a major component of many states’ budgets and is also used to fund government programs. Some state governments use a portion of the revenues for education, while others devote it to other purposes.